Understanding the Differences Between Adaptive and Responsive Website Design

Responsive Design

There was a huge uproar in the search marketing and website design industry last year when Google came out and recommended responsive web design. While Google has been known to make recommendations in the past, they’ve never tackled this particular issue definitively until June, 2012. Since then, many companies have been scrambling to convert to a responsive design.

They reiterated the need for a mobile solution earlier this year when they said that they would soon stop showing web pages that improperly redirected to a different page when called up on mobile devices. The two pieces of news were combined because of a logical series of assumptions:

  1. Google wants pages to render on any device
  2. Responsive website design accomplishes the goal
  3. Google likes responsive website design
  4. Therefore, Google does not like adaptive website design

Everything is fine until you come to the conclusion. From a search perspective, properly coded adaptive websites with identical intents on all devices combined with proper transfer of HTML content are just as easy to rank well on Google as responsive website design.

As I researched this, I found one things that was disturbing and that needs to be addressed. The opinions most commonly expressed by companies weighing in on the debate between between responsive website design versus adaptive website design always ran parallel with the offerings of the company posting the opinion. If they offered responsive design, they said that responsive design was the only way to go. If they offered adaptive websites, they said that adaptive was the best way to go.

The unbiased publications that I read almost all came to the same conclusion – functionality of the site was much more important than the type of design used. In other words, if responsive design made it challenging for a website to function properly on mobile devices, then adaptive websites were recommended. If the flow was fine between devices and the path to turning to responsive design was an easy one, then that was the way to go.

I’m going to start with the “bias” on my end and finish this paragraph with the punchline. The bias is this: my company is developing responsive website design for our clients. The punchline is this: even with this knowledge, I still recommend adaptive for any website (including my clients’ websites) that are picture- and call-to-action-heavy on important pages such as inventory.

I have yet to see a responsive car dealer website that did not sacrifice functionality and speed for the sake of responsive design. I’ve seen both sides of the spectrum – websites that looked great and worked fine on mobile devices but that were bare-bones in their PC functionality and I’ve seen websites that looked great on a PC but that were too slow and rendered improperly on many mobile devices. I haven’t seen any that have done it “right” yet because of the nature of car dealer websites.

Most importantly, I’ve seen dealer websites that switched from adaptive to responsive that watched their website leads drop as a result. I have yet to see a single one that saw leads increase. This will change as responsive technology, internet speeds, third party plugins, and image crunching (especially for dealers that load up 30+ images on their vehicle detail pages) improves, but as of now responsive has been a huge flop.

I should also note that I jumped on the responsive bandwagon back in 2011 and strongly pushed for my company to adopt it way back then. Thankfully, we didn’t.

Final note on top of the other notes: for the majority of websites, responsive is likely the best solution. Car dealers have unique website formats. On any given page, especially the all-important vehicle details pages, there may be three or four plugins, a dozen calls-to-action, and dozens of photos that have to be brought in through 3G or 4G connections. The biggest difference between adaptive website design and responsive website design is when the changes are made to adjust for the device. On adaptive websites, the changes are server side, meaning that the data being sent is determined from the server before being sent to the device. With responsive design, the changes are client side, meaning that the whole web page is sent through and then the device is told how to piece it all together.

Here’s a very slanted infographic, one that actually does have some valid points (thankfully). Whoever built it likes adaptive and while they are being too harsh in my opinion about responsive, they still bring up some real challenges.

Adaptive vs Responsive Infographic

Enhanced by Zemanta

Comments

  1. says

    Great post, congratulations. I definitely think that there are niches and/or types of businesses that should not go for one or the other approach, just like you mention the car dealerships example. I am in the hospitality industry and build Hotel websites, and a hotel website selling guns are their pictures which make it difficult to build a responsive site and keep using heavy and multiple assets that become a MUST in the pc version of the site.

  2. says

    JD you certainly make a lot of sense here. I have long preferred adaptive because it does not stress the client side resources as does the large responsive libraries that must be loaded (Bootstrap). That said however, for blogs which are primarily text and few images per post, I go with CSS media queries only responsive method.

  3. says

    We decided to go down the route of Adaptive for http://www.findvauxhall.co.uk due to the nature of the site having inventory. Glad we did as the speed it much better and we could give all the user call to action in the correct places. We have done both methods, but by far the adaptive has been more popular. You just have to do it right, which so may people don’t. I agree responsive is by far the best method if you have a more simple site as it keeps the cost lower to the customer.

  4. says

    Your means of telling everything in this piece of writing
    is genuinely good, every one be able to without difficulty be aware of it, Thanks a lot.

  5. says

    Thanks for sharing your valuable information,very useful info that you provided
    Responsive and Mobile Web Designing Services in USA CANADA SINGAPORE UK

  6. says

    Once you have confirmed thnis everythung must be able to move perfectly to completion.
    It also includes information abouht the amount that needs to be deposited.
    When looking for a lawyer, researching their website and contacting theijr conveyancing team will help you find a firm
    that will cater for your needs.

  7. says

    I have been exploring for a little bit for any high-quality articles or weblog posts in this sort of house .
    Exploring in Yahoo I at last stumbled upon this
    web site. Studying this info So i am glad to show hat I hace an incredibly excellent uncanny
    feeling I found outt just what I needed. I most indubitably will make sure to don?t omit this web site and provides it
    a look on a continuing basis.

  8. says

    Check for client references as well as staff pictures to ensure that the agency operations are
    bonafide. Where are you going. Precisely.

  9. says

    In like manner take up a prolonged tale I did gotten together with my better half once
    i ended up being 15 and also he or she had been 21 years old, without a doubt I know who’s ended up being inappropriate from the era
    feeling but they was the 1st man to indicate us accurate focus as well as
    love additional then your fellas whom simply just desired to snooze
    beside me.
    Thus why don’t we return to realize, Im nineteen and possess any 4 weeks old baby at this point in addition to my husband couldnt become
    more bored with you unless of course if this individual
    are looking for sexual when camping. I had created
    our youngster through Csection along with the very first thing they
    did when he / she acquired home had been take a seat and also
    enjoy dissertation writing dwell not necessarily be sure
    most of us ended up ok no this individual wished to perform dissertation program reside.

    And now he / she simply just consumes all his time period using tobacco cooking pot as well
    as spending time with his close friends as well as in the meantime internet marketing as a sole mother the idea feels like.

    Ever before feeling of which child came to be I have done almost everything to make sure she actually is healthful in addition to happy and it has almost everything the girl requirements, I have become work along
    with become a couple of other task delivers along with this
    individual has never lifted the finger to do anything at all that can help us.
    He has been twenty five in addition to Now i’m normally the one posting employment
    software intended for your ex, and It’s my job to include our own total relationship when this
    individual didn’t have a very work I did so in addition to at of sixteen When i was working and also investing in their petrol along with tobacco
    even though this individual sat all around along
    with 4 accomplished this each and every time this individual has been fired or laid off.

    In addition to at any time he keeps the infant the girl meows in addition to
    they will not try to calm her he or she just palms the woman’s to myself also it smashes the center because this individual missed out on bonding together
    with the woman’s and also all people about you
    could see the idea, my mums always wondering myself
    the way we are generally doing along with brings up precisely how the girl
    can certainly notify internet marketing unsatisfied and that the little one may think that while i get miserable as well as harassed
    as well as We don’t need to do of which.
    your a whole lot worse component can be When i don’t have any buddy to be
    able to talk to as well as he or she continues expressing he will instruct myself to drive rather than will and i will be noticed that you feel like
    this individual will it to keep myself trapped and also singled out, he or
    she can’t discover the reason im thus miserable dissertation writing but
    anytime My partner and i try to speak to him or her over it their responds
    consist of yep, okay, sure, and the best I’ll change…
    Could not matter how much instances he has mentioned
    I will alter along with do good for each day after which it went back in order to his shitty means.

    We dont know what i am wanting to know along
    with Im undecided exactly what in addition to convey I can go on all night about
    how precisely small awareness they indicates inside me
    and also the little one nonetheless it might you need to be excessive wording writing dissertaton
    Since enquired underneath My business is basically currently managing my own mothers and fathers with
    all the child along with this individual life together with his
    father however he / she hasn’t already basically eventually
    left my mom and dad but even so We have asked in addition to the mother and father hold asking just how long they plans
    on staying.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>