The Godfather and Social Media

Vito as StumbleUpon?In many ways, the top level websites of social media can be compared to the fictional world of The Godfather.  Sounds weird?  Hear me out.

The Godfather showed us a world of beauty and corruption.  Alliances were made and broken.  Those who were good to the family were rewarded, while anyone who stepped in the way was hit.

Social media works in much the same way.  It can be beautiful, offering the best of the web compiled into loosely organized areas where masses of people can flood a worthy website and enjoy its offerings.  It can be corrupt, as spammers use the power of social media to drive traffic to unworthy websites.

Websites can form alliances with social media partners, whether it’s a collaboration between The Wall Street Journal and Digg, Wired and Reddit, or even something as simple as placing buttons on stories to drive traffic to and from the social media platforms.

If a website is good to the family, they are rewarded.  Rawstory.com receives a huge portion of their traffic from social media.  Then again, if you wrong the family and its members, your website can get banned.

To make it as a social media website,you somehow have to fit into the family. Here’s how the breakdown of the family looks today…

Reddit as Sonny CorleoneReddit as Sonny Corleone:
For a while reddit has been considered the “hothead” of the social media family. Just like Santino “Sonny” Corleone, Reddit is simple to understand but almost impossible to comprehend. The top headlines on any particular day can include ranting, raving, cursing, and insults as exemplified by the judgemental, down-modding mentality.

Successful submissions on Reddit require a firm yet respectful voice, especially with the title. Just as Sonny would back hand any man for speaking out of turn, so too will reddit users doom a story to oblivion if it isn’t titled properly.

The best part about Reddit/Sonny is straightforward simplicity.  Within 5 minutes of meeting Sonny or joining Reddit, anyone can get a feel for how they work.  Submitting to reddit is easy: URL, Title, and a choice of 8 categories.  Requires very little thought and even less effort.

Propeller as Fredo CorleonePropeller as Fredo Corleone:
When Netscape first decided to be a Digg clone of sorts, they assumed that their name and age would be enough to help them ascend to full Godfather status. Frido was Michael’s older brother but still had to answer to his power, just as Propeller (Netscape) is trying to catch up in stature to the three-year-old Digg.

In many ways Propeller has features that are superior to the other major social media websites. They are good to their people, catering and supportive. If you have a story make it to the front page there are different things that give Propeller the “human touch” factor that its competitors do not have. They’ll manually select and attach relevant pictures to your story. They’re anchors feature five hand-picked submissions at a time in their recommended section at the top of the homepage, and they make it super simple to vote for your friends’ stories.

Still, Propeller is not the Godfather.  The website works exceptionally well for a large chunk of the social media crowd, but it would be difficult to see them make it to full Godfather status.

Digg as Michael CorleoneDigg as Michael Corleone:
With more direct traffic than the other social media websites combined, Digg is the current Godfather.  Choices made by Digg and by the masses of its members can make or break a story or a website.  When Michael spoke, people got buried.  When Digg speaks, servers can be shut down.

The media focus is always on Digg, just as with Michael.  Its popularity has been a tremendous driving force in the growth of social media as a whole.  If you ask Kevin Rose what he thought, would he say something like, “Every time I think I’m out they pull me back in.”?

Newsvine as Tom HagenNewsvine as Tom Hagen:
One look at Robert Duvall’s character in The Godfather and you knew he wasn’t quite a Corleone.  One look at Newsvine, and you can tell that something is different.  A social news website that caters to the handful of people who don’t have SM-ADHD, Newsvine is more appealing to those who have the time and want to spend it.

Still, it doesn’t quite fit in.  It’s pretty, for one thing, with lots of pictures and a design completely different from the rank-and-file style of the other SM sites.  Like Tom Hagen, Newsvine is the quiet voice of reason.  Like Tom Hagen, Newsvine doesn’t want to be in control, shoved into the spotlight that comes with being a Corleone.  Newsvine is the “Consigliare” of Social Media.

StumbleUpon as ________:
This was a tough one.  Is Stumble the Vito Corleone of social media?  You tell me.

* * *

Check out our other informative articles about social news.


About JD Rucker

+JD Rucker is Editor at Soshable, a Social Media Marketing Blog. He is a Christian, a husband, a father, and founder of Dealer Authority. He drinks a lot of coffee, usually in the form of a 5-shot espresso over ice. Find him on Twitter, Facebook, and Pinterest.

Comments

  1. I think that Stumbleupon is Sonny’s son, that became the Don when Michael Corleone just handed him the reigns in Godfather 3. That’s what Digg is doing, just handing the reigns over to Stumbleupon in a way. I prefer SU to find new sites, but I still love Digg. Just wish they weren’t so far to the left politically. Stumble is at least middle of the road and not reliant on the various factions as much as Digg, and definitely Reddit. Aside from Social Media I love to read up on politics and it gets a bit annoying to read of blaming America for all of the ills of the world.
    So little by little I see Stumble growing in power but still have that initial love of Digg – or Michael Corleone.

  2. Vincent. I never thought of that one. Tempted to edit the story. Nice add, Michael.

    “You say the word Uncle Mike. I’ll make him dead.”

  3. I know it’s not the rave now a day, but what about slashdot? I don’t think it as the ugly cousin. Or maybe is just too tech oriented to make it in your list (similar to techmeme).

  4. Fulano Detal says:

    @ jose:

    Slashdot would be Mo Green, since he was “taken out” by Michael even though Mo paved the way for him to become successful. ;p

    Michael: The Corleone family wants to buy you out.
    Mo: Buy me out? You don’t buy me out, I buy you out!

    (cut to Cmdrtaco with a bullet through his eye!)

  5. There is a whole world of creative possibilities beyond digg.

    For example, getting to top influencers to promote your product/service. Thus, generating word-of-mouth recommendations and increased sales.

    Get started by finding top influencers using Bees and Pollen FREE services:

    http://www.beesandpollen.com/st/u.aspx

  6. Sooner or later, Google will find all new spam methods.
    It has the highest ROI (Return of Invesment) in all advertisement channels.
    There are other ways to improve your ranking in Googlemaps, the purpose
    of this blog post is not to tell you EVERYTHING Frederick Web Promotions
    can do to improve your ranking, the purpose of this particular blog post is to:.

Speak Your Mind

*