46% of the Digg Front Page is Controlled by 50 Websites

Recent changes and restrictions made by Digg.com to encourage diversity in the range of users whose submissions reach the front page have had 2 profound results. Newer and less active users have seen their stories reach the front page, but the sources that are able to hit the front page have tightened.

Despite tens of thousands of submissions every week, the last seven days have shown that 46.6% of the Digg front page comes from 50 websites, according to data accumulated on di66.net.

Di66

The algorithm that Digg.com uses to determine which user-submitted content reaches the front page is in a constant state of flux. With millions of users and over 10,000 submissions per day, the site has been a target for spammers and casual social media enthusiasts who want their content to hit and reap the benefits of tens of thousands of visitors in a short period of time.

To combat the “algorithm gamers” and “power-users” on the site, Digg has launched several measures to discourage the practice of blind digging where users digg hundreds of stories quickly in hopes that others will reciprocate.  The most recent restriction allows users to Digg approximately 200 stories in a 24 hour period before getting a “Whoa Cowboy” message.  Once the limit is reached, they cannot Digg again until they go below the 24 hour threshold.

Digg: Diversify or Die

While the site has succeeded in putting new users on the front page, most of them are getting there by submitting from “whitelisted” sites. In many ways, Digg has become the personal RSS feed for sites like TorrentFreak, xkcd, and Cracked as the vast majority of submissions from these and other sites will hit the front page regardless of the submitter.  Major news sites such as Telegraph, NYTimes, and Time receive millions of visits from Digg every month.

Digg grew as a source for cutting edge, hard to find pieces of content, but over the years has shifted to the safety of “going with what works”. New sites are finding stronger exposure from social media websites like Reddit, StumbleUpon, and even Twitter where the strength of the content is a more important factor than the strength of the domain name.

It isn’t completely Digg’s fault. They have been the focal point of attempts to “game the system” for a long time and have tried to implement countermeasures against it.  When a site gets pushed too hard through shouts, IMs, and other methods of inflating Digg counts, the spam portion of the algorithm recognizes it and prevents these sites from hitting.  Some sites get banned, but most are simply filtered out by not allowing these sites to get recommended in the upcoming section. These submissions can get 200, even 300 Diggs and never hit the front page.

While this form of “autobury” is a necessary component to prevent spam, it also makes it exceptionally difficult for websites to hit the front page more than once or twice if they are not already accepted as whitelisted by the algorithm. Great content that receives tremendous approval on other social media sites doesn’t have a chance on Digg if the domain cannot make it passed these filters.

There are ways that Digg can encourage great content from a more diverse range of websites without compromising quality by allowing spam to hit. Are they willing to pursue these ways?

Do they want to diversify the front page?

If so, are they willing to ask for help?

When less than 1% of the sites submitted control 46% of the front page, diversity is dead.

* * *

JD Rucker is a social media strategist and blogger in Orange County, CA. He operates this Social Media Blog and is on Digg and Twitter, Reddit, and StumbleUpon.

About JD Rucker

+JD Rucker is Editor at Soshable, a Social Media Marketing Blog. He is a Christian, a husband, a father, and Director of Digital Marketing for KPA. He drinks a lot of coffee, usually in the form of a 5-shot espresso over ice. Find him on Twitter, Facebook, and Pinterest.

Comments

  1. Thanks for sharing very interesting article

  2. wow! Thanks for sharing very interesting article. nice blog

  3. this is something which i m searching thanks for sharing.

  4. Read it, Very informative

    Thanks

  5. Hmm…. very nice!

  6. Thanks a ton for sharing this valuable information , this post will be very useful not only to someone who is new but also to the experienced webmaster. keep up the good work. looking forward for your next post.

  7. Thanks a ton for sharing this valuable information , this post will be very useful not only to someone who is new but also to the experienced webmaster. keep up the good work. looking forward for your next post.

  8. Thanks a for sharing this information .

  9. I think digg is getting worst day by day..i don’t think backlisting any websites is a good bet.

  10. Thanks a for sharing.

  11. I would like to thank you for the efforts you have put in writing this blog. I’m hoping the same high-grade website post from you in the future also. Actually your creative writing abilities has encouraged me to get my own web site going now. Actually blogging is spreading its wings and growing rapidly. Your write up is a good example.

  12. trying to link back to site and i will do the same for you all you have to do is ask thanks

  13. trying to link back to site and i will do the same for you thanks

Trackbacks

  1. [...] today, I probably haven’t visited the site in over one year. So when I stumbled across this Digg article explaining that the Digg homepage is controlled by 50 websites, it confirms what everyone sensed [...]

  2. [...] as good as you might think: Soshable.com tracked every “front page” story on Digg for a week, and found 46.6% of Digg’s [...]

  3. [...] as good as you might think: Soshable.com tracked every “front page” story on Digg for a week, and found 46.6% of Digg’s [...]

  4. [...] analisi del Blog Soshable, il quale evidenzia che secondo i report statistici di di66.net, il 46% delle notizie che finiscono [...]

  5. [...] did a similar study yesterday.  It turns out that they found out that 46% of the Digg front page is controlled by 50 [...]

  6. [...] 46% of the Digg front page is controlled by 50 Web sites [...]

  7. [...] 46% of the Digg Front Page is Controlled by 50 Websites | Soshable | Social Media Blog Is digg unfair? (tags: socialmedia media social stats trends digg) [...]

  8. [...] via @guykawasaki 46% of the Digg Front Page is Controlled by 50 Websites | Soshable | Social Media B… [...]

  9. [...] via @guykawasaki 46% of the Digg Front Page is Controlled by 50 Websites | Soshable | Social Media B… Possibly related posts: (automatically generated)Recruitment 2.0Speaking at Graphing Social Patterns « Lightspeed Venture Partners BlogThe Friendly Chat: Joël CéréGirls talking smak: New social news site launches, just for women [...]

  10. [...] 46% of the Digg Front Page is Controlled by 50 Websites Algunas anotaciones [...]

  11. meneame.net says:

    El 46% de la página principal de Digg es controlada por 50 webs…

    [c&p] En los últimos siete días, los datos acumulados en di66.net, han demostrado que el 46,6% de las noticias que llegan a la página principal de Digg provienen de solamente 50 sitios web. Los cambios recientes en las políticas y restricciones…

  12. [...] Rucker, who wrote the Soshable post, says Digg needs to diversify, unless it wants to die:When less than 1% of the sites submitted [...]

  13. [...] A Truly Social Web Can Only Happen in the Church Hello there! If you are new here, you should subscribe to the RSS feed for updates! // The reports are true and have been screaming around the interwebs faster than people digg the newest bomb from The Huffington Post: Digg.com is not as “socially” driven as people would like to believe. [...]

  14. [...] 20, 2009 in web2.0Tags: broadcasting, digg, new media soshable found 46.6% of Digg’s front page comes from only 50 [...]

  15. [...] it doesn’t help when lists like this one from Soshable.com indicate that nearly half of all Digg front page stories come from the same group of [...]

  16. [...] de supermercados, ‘carne de cañón’- Critica televisiva: “El Vertedero”- El 46% de la portada de Digg es controlada por 50 webs- Sorteo de cuartos de final y semifinales de la Liga de Campeones- 400 vascos ya reciben en casa [...]

  17. [...] 46% of the Digg Front Page is Controlled by 50 Websites | Soshable | Social Media Blog [...]

  18. [...] 46% of the Digg Front Page is Controlled by 50 Websites: Coincidence? You be the judge of that: HorsePower Link Posted by petrimaatta Arkivert i webdesign ·Tags: digg, [...]

  19. [...] source. Twitter is just faster! And it also becomes irrelevant because of the “power-user” / “power-sites” bull***t – seams that Digg is slowly loosing the [...]

  20. [...] All companies know that they can’t please everyone though. But it doesn’t help when lists like this one from Soshable.com indicate that nearly half of all Digg front page stories come from the same group of [...]

  21. [...] 46% of the Digg Front Page is Controlled by 50 Websites | Soshable | Social Media Blog"Despite tens of thousands of submissions every week, the last seven days have shown that 46.6% of the Digg front page comes from 50 websites, according to data accumulated on di66.net." (digg Stats ) [...]

  22. [...] it doesn’t help when lists like this one from Soshable.com indicate that nearly half of all Digg front page stories come from the same group of [...]

  23. [...] who just found out that only a handful of sites really make it to the homepage now according to Soshable.com.  However, after finding Diggfrontpage.com suddenly I feel like a Dugg up Tweet.  This is a new [...]

  24. [...] It’s no secret that mainstream news sites are experiencing increased exposure on social news sites like Digg. Back in March Soshable noted that 46% of the Digg front page is controlled by 50 websites. [...]

  25. [...] that Reddit would be more resistant to the censorship that plagues Digg (such as the AACS ban and white-listing a select few sites that control 46% of [...]

  26. [...] majority of the front page will still be dominated by a handful of domains and even few submitters. 50 websites take up 46% of Digg’s front page space, and the “mainstream authority” of these sites even suggests there might be some sort [...]

  27. [...] reduced the diversity of stories that end up on the featured page. One study concluded that 46% of Digg’s front page is controlled by as few as 50 websites. Not surprisingly, these 50 websites represent some of the biggest, most well-funded players on the [...]

  28. [...] Il 46% della homepage di Digg è controllato da soli 50 siti web. Un dato impressionante se ci [...]

  29. [...] really doesn't deserve to be there but Digg has taken up measures for that and that seldom happens. 46 percent of the Digg front page is controlled by 50 Whitelisted sites writes JD Rucker a huge social media enthusiast. This is a measure by Digg where it puts more trust [...]

  30. [...] 21 front-page articles. In contrast, last year, social media watching firms thought it was a big deal that 50 different sites controlled 46% of the Digg front page. … I can understand Facebook [...]

Speak Your Mind

*